Since 2008, Middletown has honored its top student-athletes with the designation of "Athlete of the Month," with each getting a certificate from the athletic department. Their names are placed on a plaque within the high school. A poster of their accomplishent also hangs at MHS and at co-sponsor ShopRite on Route 211.
Athlete of the Month archive
2008-2009 school year
2009-2010 school year
2010-2011 school year
2011-2012 school year
2012-2013 school year
2013-2014 school year
2014-2015 school year
2015-2016 school year
2016-2017 school year
2017-2018 school year
2018-2019 school year